Mike Carruthers

Mike Carruthers

Sales Associate
Coldwell Banker King Thompson
2288 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43209-2335

Mike Carruthers is one of the premier real estate agents in Columbus.  Mike has consistently delivered exceptional service and results to his clients.  Mike's slogan is "Nobody Knows Bexley Better."  And while that is true, Mike also specializes in high-end properties throughout the greater Columbus area, particularly on the east and northeast sides of the city.  Mike is also a member of the Luxury Real Estate Group, top area agents who meet regularly to tour high-end properties and share marketing ideas.

Mike's small team has consistently been recognized as the Top Listing, Selling and Closing Agent for Coldwell Banker King Thompson Bexley's office for several years now. For the last five years Mike has been the #1 Top Agent in all of Coldwell Banker King Thompson's Columbus area offices. Mike's 28+ years of experience in the real estate industry has made him the most sought-after agent by clients because of his genuine talent for helping people buy the right home for the best price.  Mike's marketing strategy is absolutely the best in the industry in selling homes.

In a local class for real estate agents about professionalism in the real estate industry, attendees were asked, "if you were going to sell your home and use an agent other than yourself, who would you use and why?"  Mike was cited as that agent and was described as being "decent, kind, fair, professional and the nicest guy in the world" among other glowing reviews.  One agent said, "I don't even feel bad when he beats me out on a listing (which he always does) because I know the homeowner has a great realtor."

Mike's service to his clients is enhanced by his team members, Leigh Ann Wobst and Forrest Neuswanger. 

Leigh Ann is a former real estate attorney turned real estate agent who shares Mike's commitment to providing each client with exceptional service and results.  Leigh Ann also knows Bexley, having lived in the community for thirty years.  

Forrest grew up in Columbus, but then spent twenty years in Japan.  Before becoming a real estate agent, Forrest taught Japanese at Denison University in Granville.  His ability to connect with people from all walks of life make him an invaluable member of Mike's team.

As Mike's clients tell you in this video testimonial, Mike provides exceptional service when it comes to the three most important criteria in listing your home with any realtor:

1.  The ability to understand and show the house in the most favorable light.

2.  To help the clients understand the market and how to optimize their postion.

3.  To provide expert assistance in negotiations once an ideal buyer is found.




Proven Results:

  • Sold volume in 2016:  $45,000,000
  • Sold volume in 2015: $40,000,000 
  • Sold volume in 2014: $32,500,000
  • Mike sold the highest priced property ever sold in Bexley for $2,750,000

Coldwell Banker King Thompson Awards:

  • #1 Small Team in all Coldwell Banker area offices - 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016
  • International President’s Premier – 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016
  • Top Listing/Selling/Closing Small Team Bexley Office – 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016
  • #1 Brightest Star (Top Agent in all Coldwell Banker area offices) –  2013, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016


USAA Certified Agent

CARTUS Relocation Agent      

"We didn't want this blurred week of packing and moving to pass without thanking you for everything! We feel that there are very few times you work with someone that is truly exceptional in their profession, and at turns you exceeded our expectations.  Thank you for your tireless efforts during our home search journey.."

  -Liz and Andy, Bexley, OH, Client

"Mike Carruthers did a fantastic job in all aspects of the transaction. I felt that he was knowledgeable, listened to our needs, and was extremely responsive."

  -Craig & Justin, Bexley, OH, Client

"This was the sale of an estate property that was difficult...and Mike was very helpful in assisting the estate to move the process along - very much appreciated his assistance!"

  -Misty, Columbus, OH, Client

"Mike has thoroughly gone to bat for us on the sale of our last home, buying this home and then selling it. He is the best of the best. We give his name to everyone."

  -Judy and Chuck, Gahanna, OH, Client

"Mike Carruthers was wonderful! From inspections to repairs.. Mike made every aspect of our transaction work. We are so grateful and would recommend him to anyone!"

  -Sonja & Adam, Bexley, OH, Client