Mike Carruthers


Mike Carruthers

Mike Carruthers

Phone: M: 614.620.2640 614.620.2640 mobile
Phone: O: 614.324.4321 614.324.4321 office
Office: Coldwell Banker King Thompson
2288 E Main St
Columbus, OH 43209-2335


The Mike Carruthers Team is a small and dedicated group of Real Estate advisors and advocates.


We’re committed to helping you achieve everything you hope for and more. Serving you with the highest levels of ethics, integrity and exceeding your expectations at every turn. As experts in the science and art of the negotiation process, we’ll help you attain the best results from the successful purchase or sale of your home. We understand that the buying and selling process can be complicated and difficult. So, we make it our mission to take on all the responsibilities and work to support you and your family from the beginning to the end.


Meet Our Team:

Mike Carruthers is the number one agent and number one small team at Coldwell Banker King Thompson, the number one Brand in the Columbus area. Coldwell Banker is the most recognized Real Estate Brand in the country and the world leveraging the Combined Powers of #1.


Mike Carruthers is a life-long citizen of Bexley and has enjoyed nearly 30 years as top agent in Bexley, as well as Coldwell Banker King Thompson Columbus. Mike offers a simple reason for his record of success. “I dedicate myself to my clients, working harder to make certain they receive everything they need and desire. I provide them with calm and honest support. I'm their go-to expert and resource for whatever comes up. When it comes to the deal, I play hard and fair to ensure the best outcome for them." Mike's service to his clients is enhanced by his team members, Forrest Neuswanger and Olivia Urling.



Forrest Neuswanger spent his first career as a successful professor teaching for 20 years in Japan and Oxford. "I enjoy Real Estate for many of the same reasons I loved teaching. I get to help support and educate all different kinds of people at a crucial time in their lives. If I do my job, I get to make a lasting difference in their life.” Forrest brings his unique brand, patience and care to all his clients, who come from many different walks of life, from first-time buyers to those looking to sell and progress to something bigger.



As the newest member of the Mike Carruthers Team, Olivia Urling has spent the past few years working in the real estate industry as administrative support staff. "From my experience in working in the real estate world, I understand the importance of a smooth transaction from start to finish. Purchasing or selling a home is one of the biggest decisions you can make and making that process easier is my biggest goal". Olivia assists the team in transaction coordination and marketing strategies to provide clients with the best experience possible.



As Mike's clients tell you in this video testimonial, Mike provides exceptional service when it comes to the three most important criteria in listing your home with any realtor:

1.  The ability to understand and show the house in the most favorable light.

2.  To help the clients understand the market and how to optimize their position.

3.  To provide expert assistance in negotiations once an ideal buyer is found.

Proven Results:

  • Sold Volume in 2017: $56,000,000
  • Sold volume in 2016:  $45,000,000
  • Sold volume in 2015: $40,000,000 
  • Sold volume in 2014: $32,500,000
  • Mike sold the highest priced property ever sold in Bexley for $2,750,000


Coldwell Banker King Thompson Awards:

  • #1 Small Team in all Coldwell Banker area offices - 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017
  • International President’s Premier – 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017
  • Top Listing/Selling/Closing Small Team Bexley Office – 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017
  • #1 Brightest Star (Top Agent in all Coldwell Banker area offices) –  2013, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017


USAA Certified Agent

CARTUS Relocation Agent        

"We didn't want this blurred week of packing and moving to pass without thanking you for everything! We feel that there are very few times you work with someone that is truly exceptional in their profession, and at turns you exceeded our expectations.  Thank you for your tireless efforts during our home search journey.."

  -Liz and Andy, Bexley, OH, Client

"Mike Carruthers did a fantastic job in all aspects of the transaction. I felt that he was knowledgeable, listened to our needs, and was extremely responsive."

  -Craig & Justin, Bexley, OH, Client

"This was the sale of an estate property that was difficult...and Mike was very helpful in assisting the estate to move the process along - very much appreciated his assistance!"

  -Misty, Columbus, OH, Client

"Mike has thoroughly gone to bat for us on the sale of our last home, buying this home and then selling it. He is the best of the best. We give his name to everyone."

  -Judy and Chuck, Gahanna, OH, Client

"Mike Carruthers was wonderful! From inspections to repairs.. Mike made every aspect of our transaction work. We are so grateful and would recommend him to anyone!"

  -Sonja & Adam, Bexley, OH, Client

"Mike and Kim went out of their way to get this deal closed, saving me a lot of time!"

  -Susan, Bexley, OH, Client

"Want to say Mike and Kim were truly great partners considering the fact I live overseas and needed a lot of special assistance in representation. Thanks!"

  -Nathan, Columbus, OH/Hong Kong, Client

"Mike's knowledge of Bexley helped with our comfort level in moving to a new (and previously unknown) area. His colleague, Kim Snowberger, helped extensively in both showing us houses when Mike wasn't available and taking a personal interest in our move. They make a great team and I will recommend them whenever I can. Mike was great about anticipating my interest in properties coming on the market."

  -Monica and Padraig, Bexley, OH, Client

Recent Sales

Featured picture for the property 217001096
Bexley, OH
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker King Thompson
Featured picture for the property 216009398
Bexley, OH
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker King Thompson
Featured picture for the property 217003966
Bexley, OH
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker King Thompson
Featured picture for the property 215036585
Columbus, OH
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker King Thompson